When God Invites Us to Reason with Him: Isaiah, Job, and Romans
Come, Let Us Reason Together — An Invitation from God
If you have ever watched a legal drama on television, you may be familiar with the terms used in a trial. There is a plaintiff who brings the complaint of wrongdoing against someone. Then there is a defendant: the person accused of the wrongdoing. And, of course, there is a judge who decides or arbitrates the case. This person is an impartial third party who makes a binding decision.
In Isaiah 1:18, God tells Israel,
"'Come now, and let us reason together,'Says the LORD, 'Though your sins are like scarlet, They shall be as white as snow; Though they are red like crimson, They shall be as wool.'"
At first glance, it seems that God is talking about having a simple discussion or philosophical debate but that is not what the word "reason" is referring to. In Hebrew, it is yākaḥ, which carries with it a legal or courtroom meaning. When God invites us to reason with Him, it is not simply a matter of God presenting His case and Israel listening. He is inviting them to consider what He says and respond to Him. God's desire is repentance and restoration. In this chapter God is both the judge and the plaintiff who brings the charges.
God Presents Israel's Case
God presents Israel with a list of sins they are guilty of, including empty rituals, idolatry, and oppression of the poor and widows. If they are willing to repent and obey, there would be reconciliation instead of judgment. As judge, He knows they are guilty, and as the plaintiff, He knows the wrongs they have committed. But He offers them the possibility of being cleansed of their sin instead of the destruction they deserve.
Job Wants to Reason with God
In the book of Job we read again this kind of courtroom language. In Job 13:3, Job speaks to God,
"But I would speak to the Almighty, And I desire to reason with God."
Here Job is the plaintiff. His friends have accused Job of secret sins that have caused God to punish him. Job wants to ask God for the list of charges against him. Job believes he has been treated unjustly, and he wants God to explain why. If Job has sinned, God will surely know. Job wants his name cleared of these charges.
But Job must also act as a defendant. He must defend himself against the charges of his three friends who have accused him of sinning. Job is not implying he is perfect, but he is not the wicked secret sinner they believe he is.
God also becomes the defendant. Job wants God to explain why an innocent man is being treated like an enemy. Job can't reconcile his own suffering with his understanding of God's justice. Job quite literally wants God to explain Himself, but He never does.
Job warns his friends that they will be rebuked by God for lying about his character. Job believes that his willingness to go before God to defend himself will prove his innocence. But first, Job has two conditions (Job 13:20-22). One, God must not fill him with terror so he can present his case. Second, God can either ask questions and Job will answer, or God can let Job speak first and then God can respond. Job wants to know exactly what he is being charged with.
God Questions Job
In Job 38-42, instead of answering Job's question, God asks him 70 questions about the functioning of the universe. Why does God do this? He does this to show Job that the complex universe is controlled by His wisdom, and this wisdom is incomprehensible to Job. Humbled, Job realizes he was trying to judge a case without all the facts.
Job no longer presses his case. Coming face to face with God, Job acknowledges that he was talking about things he didn't understand. However, Job is finally vindicated when God tells his three friends, "You have not spoken of me what is right, as my servant Job has" (Job 42:7).
God never explains the reason for allowing Job's suffering. Yet He doesn't rebuke Job for asking. God does, however, correct Job for thinking he could judge His actions without understanding them (Job 38:2; 40:8). Job does get the encounter with God he wanted, but not the explanation he expected. He leaves humbled by the realization that he does not have all the answers.
God's Justice and Forgiveness
In Romans 3:21-26, Paul returns to the problem of God's justice and forgiveness using similar courtroom language as that of Isaiah chapter one. Paul explains in Romans 3:9-20 that the whole world stands guilty of sin before God and must be held accountable.
Now, in a human courtroom, if a person was found guilty and the judge did not punish them, the judge would be considered unjust. And yet, in Isaiah 1:18 the guilt of Israel's sins has been promised to be washed white as snow, if they are willing to turn from their sin and be obedient. So how can God forgive without being unjust?
Jesus Makes Forgiveness Possible
Paul's explanation of this seeming contradiction is that it is resolved through Jesus. It is Jesus who takes the legal penalty of sin upon Himself on the cross. This is why Paul says that God, in His patience, “passed over former sins” (Romans 3:25), including the sins of Israel in Isaiah’s day. His justice isn't compromised because the penalty was always going to be paid at the cross.
As Paul says, this allows God to be both just and the justifier. He is faithful to the law and at the same time declaring guilty sinners, you and I, righteous through Christ. We have been declared righteous, not because of our own righteousness, but because of Christ's.
As our great Judge, He doesn't ignore truth or turn a blind eye to wrongs. He defends the innocent and rescues the guilty. In Isaiah, God brings the charge, but Scripture also shows that Satan accuses us. Satan acts as our accuser by bringing charges against us before God (Revelation 12:10). But Hallelujah our sins have been washed clean, as white as snow, by the sacrifice of the Lamb on the cross. God no longer remembers the sins we have repented of because they have been freely forgiven forever (Hebrews 8:12).
How Do We See Ourselves?
We may be like Israel, in the midst of great sin, soon to be judged, and seemingly without hope. But repentance is ever a possibility. We can turn from our sin and turn to the One who loves us so dearly. But Scripture tells us that today is the day and now is the time (2 Corinthians 6:2). We are not promised tomorrow.
We may be like Job, in the midst of suffering for no apparent reason, being judged by those around us as though "maybe we deserved it." Perhaps you lost your job through no fault of your own and you hear gossip that it was because of a personal failure. But God is on His throne. He sees and knows all that we don't, and we can submit humbly to His will. In the end, God blessed Job's faithfulness because He is faithful.
Today, who are you? In our relationship with Him, we may see ourselves as the plaintiff, the defendant, or the judge. Most of us probably see ourselves as defendants, but instead of acknowledging our wrongdoing, we may try to defend or justify ourselves to God, much as Adam did in the garden. As the plaintiff, we may blame God for our suffering. We might even try to judge God because we don't understand why things happen.
Just know this courtroom drama has continued through the ages and will until Christ returns. When God says, "Come now, and let us reason together," He doesn't just ask us to listen to Him, but invites us to respond. We can trust that His righteous justice will always be perfect.





Comments